Saturday, June 23, 2012

Newer News

If you couldn't tell, my writing energies have been funneled into sermons and liturgy lately.  This occasion for writing has been a stretch and challenge for me- as now I have a very specific context for writing liturgy and sermons- and I'm not sure others would follow what I am writing.  Therefore, I am not brave enough to post anything here.  One day, when I am in a different place, I'll read over my material again with fresh eyes and see if there's anything useful about it for any of you, dear readers.

With summer has come eating out of the garden again.  Fresh fruit, organic veggies from the CSA, fresh-baked breads on Sabbath- I love eating this time of year.  This year, I am helping maintain a communal garden.  This year also happens to be rather dry.  There's lots of rain dancing and hardly much success.  The rare rainy nights seem like small miracles.

Again, I hear a call from God to dwell with the outcasts and strangers.  I still don't know what this looks like or where to begin.  I see glimpses, but when I chase after them they disappear.  Part of me wonders if I will look back at this time of my life and think that I was quite blind to all the signs.  Blindness is hardly a condition one can overcome alone.  Rural life is very isolating, but then again so is living in the middle of a big city.  I will just wait and see what happens.  I'm not sure what this time is supposed to be about.  Patience?

Thursday, April 26, 2012

Tension (and release?)

I must admit that I'm still a bit of a newcomer to the whole "diversity of opinions" sort of thing in the church.  The Southern Baptist Church is pretty good at avoiding that whole problem within its denomination.  Presbyterians, however, seem to live with tension all the time.  The two sides (in reality there are way more than 2 opinions, but we tend to be a 2-sided sort of country right now) use their own vocabulary to describe the world, and I've just recently found a nice way to line them up:

1. If we err, we should err on the side of righteousness.
2. If we err, we should err on the side of grace.

It's not that either camp sides completely with one or the other, but it seems that a camp tends to favor one over the other.  Of course what's being described here is the dialectical tension between God's grace and God's justice- we can neither fully reject one nor fully embrace the other, and they do not fit into neat categories side-by-side, but they wrestle with each other.  If we wish to engage the tension, we will be forced to wrestle with both.  However, we're likely pre-disposed to let one side win over the other, and it may not rely fully on our fully-rational, objective choice.

Here's an interesting write-up in Time about a recent study that shows a difference in brain structure between self-proclaimed political "conservatives" and "liberals."  Note in the article that the study's author was not clear on whether the brain influenced preference or if the preference re-mapped the brain.

So when we have "open dialogue" about issues that come up in the politics of the church, how willing are we to compromise?  Yes, an open mind is necessary in a debate if some sort of compromise is desired.  However, we don't live in a context where debates are necessarily solved in the minds of all witnesses by the power of reasoning of the "winner" of the debate.  I cannot think of a single Republican Presidential Debate during the primaries/caucuses where the majority of viewers could declare an uncontested winner.  This fact might be more telling about those particular candidates more than the state of arguments in general though.  Truly, the practice we've put into political debates, regardless of which side we took, might have taught us well how to be more entrenched in our own pre-conceived notions.  Our lack of practice in effective communication tends to leave us 20 minutes or 10 hours after a debate coming up with new arguments for the side to which we've already committed.  I'm sure you, dear Reader, remember times when you came out of a difficult debate thinking, "I should have said this instead of that.  Why couldn't I think of that in the heat of the moment!?"

Is there really such a thing a "open dialogue" then?  Can we really put ourselves into the argument of our opponent and truly question our own arguments?  Obviously we don't want to imagine our "enemy" as correct or insightful, but it might be a good practice in general.

An alternative might be simply to pursue a third way.  Third ways, while they tend to open us to the wrestling with both sides of the dialectical tension, also tend to be wildly unpopular.  Still, the simple pursuit of the third way might add value to the conversation, as it can open the imagination of those on opposite sides of the table.

So, should we err on the side of righteousness or the side of grace?  I've tended to side with grace, mostly because I'm so deeply in touch with my own depravity (thank you, SBC).  If I can be forgiven by God and neighbor, I most certainly can offer grace to those who sin against me.  But I wrestle quite often with righteousness (which I tend to pair with the notion of "justice" from the Hebrew Scriptures).  I might lean toward theological liberalism, but I also engage in some questionable practices, writing letters to my elected officials in order to "lobby" for the poor, engaging in political dialogue with my neighbors, preaching about God's justice from the pulpit- things that upset greatly the voice for the "separation of church and state" that exists in others and in myself.

Still, when I wrestle with righteousness and grace, I remember that God is not as fragile as we presume God might be.  When we read all the scripture texts where God seems to be sinfully angry and jealous, we rely on our fear (and who wouldn't be afraid of an all-powerful, all-seeing, angry God?!) to push us in the direction of protecting God.  If our sin makes God angry, why wouldn't we try and hide it from God, or protect God from the sinfulness of ourselves and others?

But if Jesus came in love and sacrifice for sinners, then maybe God isn't as angry as we thought.  If God took on flesh and didn't shoot up the place, maybe God's more gentle and understanding than we thought.  So if we decide that there's no need for fear in the Christian understanding of God, then how else might be approach God- in trust?  In love?  In compassion?  In peace?  In understanding?  In hope?

Jesus asked Peter: "Do you love me?"  Peter replied, "Yes, of course Jesus.  Of course I love you."  "Feed my sheep," replied Jesus.  Jesus, wanting to fully establish his point, does this dance 3 times in a row.  Few things in the Bible get repeated with such intensity.  Jesus really means it, y'all.

If loving God does not require protecting God from the awfulness of our sin and the sin of our neighbors, maybe we can see how closely related our love of God connects to our love of neighbor.  Does that mean we should be righteous (act justly)?  Yes.  Does it mean we should offer grace?  Yes.

My honest question out of this goes as such: Why does the church so often pick sides between an excessive protection of God's righteousness (thus leading to our excessive judgement and condemnation of each other) and an excessive grace toward neighbor (that does not hold the people we love accountable when they work very hard for the destruction of the other people we love)?  Can we hold people accountable in love and still offer grace?  What does that look like in the context of current "debates" about our common life?

Monday, April 16, 2012

First Day

So, I was asked (called?  more like contracted) to become the Interim Pastor for a congregation recently.  Today is my first day, officially.  I came to the church/pastor's study around noon, in case the previous pastor was moving anything out- I wanted to make sure she had space to say goodbye.  Now I've been here all afternoon.  Here are some impressions:

-Where is everyone?  I've been here alone all day, except for the lovely couple coming to drop off some plates for a community dinner coming up.  Still, I somehow imagined this would be a completely relational sort of vocation, but apparently pastors spend quite a bit of time alone.  Today, I mostly prayed and planned and read and wrote.  If the Spirit is going to be my only companion during the day, I think I'll get a radio so we can rock it out all day together.

-Meal planning will be interesting.  I brought 1.5 meals with me, consumed everything for lunch, so I'm now eating a grocery-store made salad with mayonnaise and bacon on top (really, Midwest?  mayo and bacon need to be on everything?!).  I live approximately 40 miles away from the church.

-There's also no coffee shop here.  I'm hoping someone will clue me in to where there is "community" happening around here.  I'm guessing it might involve taco pizza at the local gas station (and I'm not even kidding).

-The Deacons meeting is in an hour, and I am more excited about just being around people than what it is we'll discuss at the meeting.  And I'm an introvert.

-How'd it get so cold again?  And what is this I hear about snow storms possible in April?  I'm not sure I'm okay with this.

-Despite not getting to meet with people so far today, nor talking with more than the local phone directory lady calling to update the church information, I'm still super excited about this Interim Pastor thing and have unbounded energy at the moment.  Seriously, can I just dance around the office in praise to God right now?  I've been filled with dreams for years about this, and here I am in the Pastor's study, writing liturgy and reading and dancing around the office with the Spirit.

Praise be to God!

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Incarnational Theology

Jesus came in the flesh- incarnating this world fully God and fully human.

We are embodied souls, souls with bodies.

Spirited bodies.

Yes, many of us have some fleshiness issues that stem largely from Plato and plenty of others who followed.  I find myself unwilling to live in this body of mine- not because it's unfavorable most of the time- but because I'd rather find value in my mind.  I guess I feel my mind can contribute something more eternal- scholarship, compassion, education- than my body can offer.  But my body cannot be separated from these things.  My rejection of a hyper-sexualized culture or the fleeting vitality of youth does not mean I must reject my body.

So, I embraced my body yesterday.  We (my body and I) went to the park, to sit and watch the geese and take in the beautiful weather.  We took a long walk in the breezy-ness, in a breezy skirt and a long scarf.  We felt the sun on our face.  We pondered Jesus' parable of the big dinner (Luke 14) and remembered what it's like to sit with people around the table enjoying good food.  We remembered being welcomed in to the group.  We practiced our orchestral parts for next week, and we felt the vibrations of the resonate violin through our neck and face.  We could feel fourth position nicely against our wrist, and the really out-of-tune notes were like a daggers to the gut.  We talked to people and offered compassion and got a little pushy and hugged and kissed.  We did many things we normally do, but together.

When it was time to sleep, I had the same feeling that I have every night as I'm falling asleep- the almost-dream of flying through the air, looking down at all the street lights on at night, spinning and soaring.  The difference was that instead of looking at myself flying through the air, I could feel it.  It was a 1st-person dream, rather than a 3rd-person encounter.

Today, I shall live in my body again.

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

A new argument for being physically present

I was reminded yesterday that "90% of caring is just showing up", and for ministers (read: the priesthood of all believers), this is especially true.  Being a witness to the love of God most certainly involves the very rare occurrence of leaving the laptop at home, the iphone in the purse (maybe even on silent...God forbid), and giving our whole attention to someone who just needs to talk, cry, rejoice, or die.

Our digital addiction is a distraction not only from our time spent with God's people, but from awareness of the problems of the world.  How quickly we can forget that our neighbors (read: family down the street, or refugee family in Syria) make their beds in a shelter or an alley tonight when we enjoy our evening distractions and then sleep peacefully in our warm beds.  Yes, this technology can connect us with others around the world, arouse our inner fire of justice, but it can equally distract us and keep firmly the wool over our eyes.  Indeed, we often don't even need technology to distract us from the pain of others.

Yet here's a new article that might not only defend our (sometimes pathological) focus on our technology and concern for our neighbors, but get us out of the house too.  Apple's new "eyeglasses."  Yes, it's a new layer of technology, with its new realm of freedom and choices, and a new round of fear about driver safety and protection of personal information.

But what I see is that technology, as it moves toward more convenience, is actually doing the opposite of what it used to do.  Before, it kept children at home with their games, rather than pushing them outside to play ball.  It once kept parents tethered to a machine in an empty room, with distractions enough to fight off the inevitable existential battles of middle-age.  It forced families into separate realms of existence that were only broken by family dinners and electrical outages, a separation only before successfully seen through the Victorian architecture philosophy of a separate room for each person or each task.

Now, technology wants you to go outside and play.  It wants you to stay connected with your friends online so that you can visit with them in the real world.  It wants you to have the freedom to enjoy its convenience while still functioning in a basic physical capacity.  As I write this in my pajamas (it's a snow day- I see no reason to change) in the late afternoon, after spending all day working on a website, an email service, an e-newsletter, etc., I think about this battle between mental activity and physical presence often.  Of course, pastors, professors, and many others battle the realm of the overactive mind and the underactive body in many other ways that have little to do with technology.  Still, I see that as technology progresses, I'll have little excuse for sitting here in my pajamas like this in 10 years from now.  I'll be out playing in the snow, or visiting the coffee shop (wait, why am I not there now?), while I inform the church that the Wednesday night activities are cancelled due to snow.  Or maybe, we'll be having some of those activities online.  But I hope we'd never move all our activities online- I like hugging people when I share the peace of Christ with them, and breaking bread physically together.

I'll still turn it off my Apple eyeglasses/implant/brain-reader when talking to people though.  I hope that in 10 years, you can meet with a pastor and have her/his full attention, as we as a society build a respectful etiquette in relation to our devices and our fellow human beings.  I hope that if I am one day dying in my bed while my family is sitting with me, they'd have the courtesy to turn off their football game while I cross over to the other side.

Monday, February 27, 2012

What would you do?

So here is a hypothetical situation for you: you show up to the indoor track at the local gym, and you notice the sign about “track etiquette” posted on the wall.  On odd-numbered days, runners are to run counter-clockwise around the track.  On even-numbered days, runners are to run clockwise around the track.  There is only one other person running at the moment- counter-clockwise.  You quickly remember that today is an even-numbered day, so today is “clockwise” day.  You decide that you will:

A. Kindly but boldly proclaim to the man that he’s running the wrong way, thus setting him straight and keeping you from having to make the same horrid mistake to avoid a head-on collision.
B. Don’t say anything, but do the right thing by running clockwise like the sign says.  Head-on collision and strange looks might occur, but you’d rather do the right thing yourself, even if other people don’t care.
C. Run counter-clockwise also, only because it’s not a big deal.  It’s just running around a track.  Chill out already.  Poor etiquette ≠ a warrant for your arrest.
D. Run counter-clockwise because you also don’t care for anyone’s rules; did I mention that you consider yourself a rebel, and would revel in the chance to get arrested by the “track” police?  What a great story!
E. Avoid having to make a decision and go find a treadmill.

How you answer this question may or may not reveal the nature of your character and/or your reasoning skills.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Lenten discipline

I don't usually talk about my Lenten disciplines, in part because they are often too abstract for my life and they get abandoned due to lack of forethought.  However, I will share this time:

I shall challenge the notion of "progress" in my day-to-day life.

Yes, I know, this is again very abstract, but I've thought it through.  When I think of all the things that have stopped me, all the abandoned disciplines I initially took on when I moved to Waverly (practice regularly, exercise regularly, read extensively to feed the numerous translations and exegesis papers I would get to because I have the time and skills now), I realize that part of why I quit was because I wasn't sure what I was aiming for. I wanted an end-goal: a recital, a target fitness goal, and a call from a parish.  Then none of those things really happened.  While I'm sure I could find a way to schedule a recital, and just choose what I want out of my running, I really can't push the call thing.  I'm boxed in with several boundaries on the call (geographic location being one of the bigger issues), so that's a little bit harder to "accomplish."  Still, I think I am beginning to uncover one of my golden calves...the notion of progress.

After "progressing" though a music degree, my final year was spent in the purgatory of no real study, an early morning job stocking my local target, and no real direction.  Ugh.  No real thought to the present then...just what I could do to get out of that purgatory.  Then seminary was lovely enough to help me feel like I was "progressing" into a pastorate by leaps and bounds.  Life did improve greatly with a theological education.  It helped make sense of music school and the purgatory year.  I still helps me see and discern in ways I never would have otherwise.  It also gave me direction.

Yes, direction.  The trailhead.  It carries such anticipation, such purpose.  Oh, the Places You'll Go!  (I'm sure other people got that Seuss book when they graduated from high school).

Suddenly, I'm not at the trailhead anymore.  I'm not even on a trail.  I don't even know where I am.  I mean, I'm in an internship.  It seems like a trail of some sort.  But sometimes it's not.  It's not purgatory either.

I see no reason to think that I'm on some sort of road of progress right now.  I'm just being who I am, where I am for the moment.  The part of me that earns credit for hitting milestones, who is rewarded by looking back and seeing how far I've come, isn't getting fed right now.  So either I go hungry pining for the perfect meal of the future progress or I enjoy the food that is on the table at this moment- the feast of the present.

I will practice violin, not with a recital in mind, but because I love playing violin.  What will I play?  Scales, etudes, old sonatas.  Will I compare myself to how I once played them?  I might, but I won't end the conversation there, longing for the overly-glorified past or the ever-hopeful future.

I will exercise, not with the goal of a marathon or all-time record, but because it keeps me healthy, and it helps me sleep better.  I will neither compare myself to others or to my previous self.  I will just enjoy my time spent running, and, God-forbid, enjoy the fact that I am young and healthy and can still do these things.

I will wait for a call, despite feeling like a bum and a freeloader, because I know God is doing something in my life with this time.  I might translate some Hebrew, or I might not.  I'm not going to beat myself up over it anymore.

Last year for Lent, I gave up self-abuse.  It was largely successful, but now I have much more time to let the negativity gain traction.  Still, it's all embedded in these ideas of progress and hierarchy and control.  Maybe I'm just trying to say no to these things, but really, I'm saying yes to being present in this wonderful place with these wonderful people.  Besides, I didn't earn this time off (a nice way to say "underemployed"), but it is a gift from God.  I didn't bust myself in seminary and therefore become deserving of this time to rest- it's a gift freely given by God for my recovery of creativity and recentering.  I'm ready to embrace that.

What are you taking on for Lent?